Certain Songs #1210: Mott The Hoople – “I Wish I Was Your Mother”

Album: Mott
Year: 1973

The final song on Mott, “I Wish I Was Your Mother” was a folk-rock masterpiece that showcased not just Ian Hunter’s worship of all things Bob Dylan, but also Mick Ralphs proficiency with multiple stringed instruments.

Opening with a mandolin trilling over a gently-strummed acoustic guitar — one of the top three uses of a mandolin on any rock song, the other two being “Maggie May” and “Losing My Religion” — “I Wish I Was Your Mother” gets across on Hunter’s quietly resigned vocals, expertly calibrated to put pauses where you wouldn’t on lines like “is there a happy … ending . . . I don’t think so.

And then with the mandolin, a ghostly harmonica, Morgan Fisher’s piano and an ever-increasing amount of backing vocals all kicking in at the exact right amounts, “I Wish I Was Your Mother” soars into its indelible chorus.

Oh I wish I was your mother
I wish I’d been your father
‘n then I would have seen you
Would have been you as a child

Played houses with your sisters
And wrestled with all your brothers
And then who knows
I might have felt a family for a while

It’s so lovely, you might not even notice how sad it is. After a whole album about hanging with the boys in his rock ‘n’ roll band, “I Wish I Was Your Mother” could almost be seen as explaining why being in a rock ‘n’ roll band was so important to Ian Hunter in the first place: where he could feel a family for awhile.

While it wasn’t as popular as “All The Young Dudes” or “All The Way From Memphis,” it’s possible that “I Wish I Was Your Mother” has turned out to be the more indelible song. It’s been covered by artists like Dramarama, Maria McKee & Alejandro Escovedo, as well as many others even more obscure.

And it makes sense: not particularly tied to a place and time, “I Wish I Was Your Mother” hits on more universal feelings of wanting to belong to a family, makeshift or not.

“I Wish I Was Your Mother”

Every Certain Song Ever
A filterable, searchable & sortable somewhat up to date database with links to every “Certain Song” post I’ve ever written.

Check it out!

Certain Songs Spotify playlist
(It’s recommended that you listen to this on Spotify as their embed only has 200 songs.)

Support “Certain Songs” with a donation on Patreon
Go to my Patreon page

Leave a Reply