Is Zune A PlaysForSure Killer?

Earlier this week I told you the 10 things you need to know about Microsoft Zune. While that list will get you through small talk at most cocktail parties, there’s one item that merits more discussion — the fact that Zune will not be PlaysForSure Compliant.

Microsoft developed the PlaysForSure certification program in late 2004 as part of a branding campaign designed to promote products and services that were compatible the Microsoft DRM system. It was an attempt to assure consumers that they could buy any compliant player, subscribe to a compliant music service, and have a seamless digital music experience on par with anything produced by Apple.

According to Microsoft’s PlaysForSure website:

If you’re shopping for a portable music or video device and you want to make sure the digital music and video you purchase will play back on it every time, look for the PlaysForSure logo. Match the PlaysForSure logo on a large selection of leading devices and online music stores.

The reality, however, was quite a bit different. The net is filled with frustrated accounts of consumers burdened with devices and services that were never quite as compatible as they were supposed to be. No matter how much money Microsoft threw at this program they could never quite convince consumers that PlaysForSure was better than the iTunes/iPod combo.

So now, Microsoft appears to be doing the unthinkable by copying Apple’s model of tethering a portable player to an online music service and using a closed DRM system to pull it all together. It will be interesting to see how Microsoft makes this all work. Will there be a new Microsoft DRM system, or will they intentionally configure the old DRM to be incompatible with all of those PlaysForSure players on the market?

Any way you look at it Microsoft’s partners have been screwed. While Microsoft says it will continue to support the PlaysForSure program, you have to wonder how many of the participants will continue their involvement now that Microsoft has moved on to what looks to be another standard that will be incompatible with existing products.

And what will become of Urge, Microsoft’s high profile partnership with MTV? Will Microsoft suddenly be in the position of marketing it’s new product line in competition with it’s slightly less new online service?

Microsoft’s new music service will reportedly be similar to iTunes in scope. Microsoft is said to be negotiating terms with labels right now. My guess is the Zune music store (or whatever they eventually call it) will offer both subscription pricing and variable pricing on individual tracks. Microsoft will give the major labels everything Apple has refused to give them. In the process they’ll end up confusing consumers and angering their partners.

If nothing else Microsoft is doing a tremendous service for the anti-DRM movement. I’ve mentioned before that consumers who buy DRM’d music are at the mercy of the companies who manufacture and support the underlying DRM system. There’s no guarantee that any given DRM system will be supported forever. Microsoft’s seeming abandonment of PlaysForSure is a fine example of just how bad things can get.

10 Responses to “Is Zune A PlaysForSure Killer?”

  1. Uvaldo Garcia says:

    Wait a minute… you mean Bill Gates is doing something that hurts the consumer just to make more money?! Quick, somebody call Mulder and Scully because we have a case! If Bill Gates really is going to step down as CEO soon, I have to assume he is going to do all that he can to stregnthen the Microsoft brand before then. And if that means screwing business partners, then so be it! Bill might be giving away billions to charities, but he sure is a bastard when it comes to making the money in the first place. Interesting moral dicotemy…

  2. Amazing idea admin. You just help my homework for next exam Thanks admin


  1. […] Myth: Amazon’s reliance on Windows-based software could pay off after Microsoft starts selling its rival player, called Zune, later this year, according to the LA Times. Fact: As far as we know Zune won’t support the current generation of Windows Media DRM and Microsoft probably won’t license their DRM to third parties like Amazon. If Zune is a hit it will do nothing to help Amazon Unbox. […]

  2. […] We rag on Microsoft a lot around here. Zune, particularly, has come in for a lot of pre-sale criticism from these quarters. So we should praise them when they do something right. And today’s announcement that they have set up a deal with several studios to offer downloads directly to their Xbox Live service in just a couple of weeks smacks a whole hell of a lot of doing things right. […]

  3. […] We’ve been pretty hard on Zune here, noting several issues before it has even launched.. Nevertheless, I had still toyed with buying one, just to review it. It only seemed fair to maybe give it a try. I mean, after surviving the Prism DuroSport 6000, how bad could it be? But forget all of that, because I read something last night that ensures that I will never ever buy one. Microsoft is giving a percentage of the money from sales of Zune to Universal Music. […]

  4. […] Microsoft used the Zune as an opportunity to introduce an entirely new DRM system that is incompatible with the company’s previous DRM system. In the process they angered many of their partners who had built their business based on the old PlaysForSure DRM system. […]

  5. […] was just last November when Microsoft released a new media player that didn’t support the company’s own PlaysForSure DRM format. To Microsoft’s credit they continue to support the PlaysForSure DRM scheme for third […]

  6. […] Kindle uses a new Amazon file format that appears to be a new type of DRM for ebooks. While the Kindle can read books in the Mobipocket format, it can’t read DRM protected Mobipocket files. That’s odd considering that Amazon owns Mobipocket, but not so odd when you consider how Microsoft created the new Zune DRM format while largely abandoning its own PlaysForSure DRM system. […]

  7. […] The only way to do that was to control the device, the DRM, and the marketplace. And so, Microsoft abandoned PlaysForSure when it launched the Zune. By the time Microsoft came to this realization it was too late. It […]