• Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • About
  • Archives
  • Contact

Medialoper

We're Not Who You Think We Are

Could Microsoft or Apple Be the Future of EMI?

March 5, 2007 by Kirk Biglione

Like all good media dinosaurs EMI Records is in no hurry to meet the future. The status quo is just too familiar and comfortable; better hang onto it as long as you can. Last week EMI postponed the future just a little bit longer by refusing a $4.1 billion takeover bid by WMG and breaking off discussions with online music services over the possibility of selling DRM-free downloads.

You would think a company that’s rapidly losing market share and issuing profit warnings every month would be taking drastic steps to turn things around, but that’s clearly not the case with EMI. As a card carrying member of the “big four” EMI is one of the last of a dying breed. I’m pretty sure there’s something in The Endangered Species Act that prevents the company from actually going bankrupt.

There’s a chance that EMI’s head-in-the-sand approach might actually work to the company’s advantage. It’s possible that WMG’s offer could pale in comparison to what a technology company like Microsoft or Apple might pay to buy control of EMI.

EMI’s demand for an large up-front payment in order to license its music for DRM-free download is just the latest example of the difficulties that technology companies have had in dealing with the major labels. Last November UMG did everything but blackmail Microsoft into paying a per-device fee just days before the Zune product launch. Then there’s the ongoing battle between the majors and Apple over the flexibility of iTunes pricing.

At some point companies like Apple and Microsoft are going to realize it might actually be easier and cheaper to buyout the major labels than it is to continue negotiating with them every time a new product or service is launched.

A Microsoft-WMG deal or an Apple-EMI deal makes a hell of a lot more sense than a WMG-EMI deal does. The last thing the music industry needs is more consolidation among the major labels. While a WMG-EMI merger might have improved earnings for the combined company, it would have done nothing to solve the real problem the music industry is facing — a lack of innovation.

Technology companies are in a position to deliver real innovation when they can release products and services without having to negotiate every new development with labels who are more concerned about propping up a archaic business model.

The next logical question is what would happen to iTunes if Microsoft were to buy a major label. A Microsoft owned EMI could be just as difficult for Apple to negotiate with. Except that, like Apple, Microsoft has indicated they realize that DRM is a limiting factor in consumer adoption of digital media technologies. If Microsoft were to purchase EMI the most subversive thing they could do would be to give Steve Jobs exactly what he’s asking for — DRM-free music.

Besides, if Microsoft were to buy one of the majors it probably wouldn’t be long before Apple followed suit. The only question is whether or not Google and Yahoo would jump into the bidding as well.

In a decade or so it’s possible the big four might be Microsoft, Apple, Google, and Yahoo.

Filed Under: Apple, DRM, Microsoft, Music

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. Tessa says

    March 5, 2007 at 8:52 am

    It’s definitely a wild prospect to imagine Apple or Microsoft buying out EMI — though, I’d worry a bit about them pushing EMI music above everything else.

    I think a lot of the struggle EMI (and all the record companies) have is a failure to realize that times have changed. They need to adapt — and I’ve heard a few interesting ways for them to do so. One interesting way that they could increase their bottom-line is developing a way for users and small companies to legally license music. (There’s a great essay about this by Shelly Palmer.)

    Of course, there’s also the possibility advertiser-support music (which I am not necessarily excited about).

    – Tessa

  2. Javier Marti says

    March 5, 2007 at 7:09 pm

    Hi.
    I am Javier, the founder of Trendirama.com, a community of online amateur writers. We write about the future of everything, and I would like to invite you guys to write an article on the Trendirama.com website, perhaps “The future of EMI” or whatever you are passionate about? It is up to you, you choose the subject.
    You would get a link back when you link to your own article, if you wish.
    You can even re-use some of what you have here, in the last part of the article, “your view and comments”. That would save you time and still be interesting for readers.
    And yes, I know you may not have the time. None of us do…;)

    Failing that, if you like the project and you can help me to promote it and find writers/readers -even if you don’t write- it would be great. Since we are starting, we need all and any help that you can give.
    By making this valuable information available online for free, I truly believe we are helping to make the world a better place.
    And you could do your bit for the world too.

    Your help is appreciated, and if you let me know your contribution, you’ll be rewarded appropriately in due time. If you link to us or mention us, we can link you back too.
    You can even use our valuable articles on your websites, provided that you link back. Any better offer than that?! ๐Ÿ™‚

    Look forward to hearing from you or read your article in Trendirama! Join us writing an article!

    Best regards
    Javier Marti
    http://www.trendirama.com

Primary Sidebar

Lopy

Search

Previously on Medialoper

  • Certain Songs #2542: Sugar – “The Act We Act”
  • Certain Songs #2541: Sufjan Stevens – “Too Much”
  • Certain Songs #2540: Sufjan Stevens – “Djohariah”
  • Certain Songs #2539: Sufjan Stevens – “Heirloom”
  • Certain Songs #2538: Sufjan Stevens – “Casimir Pulaski Day”

Copyright © 2023 ยท Medialoper